As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases Affiliate disclosure
Where Memories Lie
Duncan Kincaid/Gemma James #12
Where Memories Lie (2008)
A plea from Gemma James’s neighbor Erika Rosenthal turns an ordinary London spring into something far more troubling. Erika, who fled Nazi Germany years earlier, has lived with a carefully guarded past, but now a valuable brooch stolen during that escape has surfaced at a prestigious London auction house. Its reappearance raises more than one question: who kept it all these years, how did it return to view, and whether the history surrounding Erika and her late husband is darker than anyone knew.
From there, the novel opens into the shadowy world of wealth, art, and old European secrets. The missing heirloom is not just a family keepsake but a link to displacement, betrayal, and wartime loss, and the case grows sharper once a new murder brings Duncan Kincaid directly into the investigation. Deborah Crombie uses the auction-house setting and London’s cultivated surfaces to create a mystery in which elegance and menace sit very close together.
The pull of Where Memories Lie comes from the way personal history refuses to stay buried. Instead of treating the past as background color, the book lets it shape the danger in the present, with questions of identity, survival, and stolen legacy driving the suspense. The result is a mystery that feels both intimate and far-reaching, moving from private grief into treachery that stretches back to the brink of war in 1939.